Rosh chodesh means new moon (lit. beginning of
the month). Isaiah 66:23:
“Every month on Rosh-Hodesh
and every week on Shabbat, everyone living will come to worship in my
presence,” says Adonai.
In Colossians 2:16-17, Sha’ul/Paul wrote,
“So don’t let anyone pass judgment on
you in connection with eating and drinking, or in regard to a Jewish festival
or Rosh-Hodesh or Shabbat. These are a shadow of things that are
coming, but the body is of the Messiah.”
Key texts used to interpret this in Christian tradition are Isa 1:13-14
(with no regard for the context) and Gal 4:10 (which speaks of the Galatians’
former pagan practices). So, participation in rosh chodesh is widely
viewed by Christians as wicked. But Sha’ul was warning his readers about
asceticism; see Col 2:20-23. Ascetic disciplines have no value in restraining
indulgence of the flesh (Col 2:16-17; also see 1 Tim 4:1-9). Does Sha’ul’s
instruction in Col 2:16 suggest his readers were or were not engaging in these
things? They were! What does the Torah prohibit on rosh chodesh?
Nothing!
A shadow leads us to the body that casts it—the body of Messiah. As
shadow helps us to picture what the body is like, the festivals help us to
foresee the age of Messiah. Shadows don’t fill in the details of depth, colour
and texture; festivals are just a foretaste of the “things that are coming”. Things
that have not come yet! What things? The Messianic era!
Gen 1:14 tells us that God made the sun and the moon for the purpose of
setting up a calendar for signs and appointed times (mo’edim). Similarly,
Ps 104:19 says, “You made the moon to mark the mo’edim.” Signs for what?
Times appointed for what?
The Bible and Apocrypha present people who celebrated rosh chodesh
as righteous (e.g. the anonymous woman from Shunem and Judith). Those who
despise rosh chodesh are presented in Amos 8 as wicked. Worse are those
who do evil but superficially observe Shabbat and rosh chodesh just to
make a good impression (Isa 1). But worst of all are those who seek to annul
the mitzvot altogether and to prohibit others from keeping them (1
Maccabees).
Now that there is no temple, Jews may not offer animal sacrifices; they
can only offer t'fillim/t’fillin: prayers in place/remembrance of the
offerings. Messianic Jews and Messianic Gentiles can participate in Jewish
customs regarding rosh chodesh, and even develop new ones.
When the temple is rebuilt, offerings for rosh chodesh will
continue (Eze 45:17). The Prince of Israel—Yeshua—and all the people of the
land will give special devotion to HaShem each rosh chodesh (Eze 46:1-3).
Why observe rosh chodesh now?
1. Eze 45:17 tells us
that the offerings atone for the house of Israel.
2. In observing rosh
chodesh, we celebrate God’s covenant faithfulness to Israel—see Jer
31:35-36.
3. Rosh chodesh speaks of the renewal! Isa 66:22-23 speaks first of the
renewal of creation (tikkun olam), and then worldwide observance of rosh
chodesh and Shabbat. Peter stated explicitly that Messiah’s return will
bring about the renewal, (Acts 3:21).
Usually, Col 2:16 is read backwards, as though the Colossians were being
judged for abstaining from the festivals, Shabbat and rosh chodesh. But
Sha’ul’s wording implies the opposite: believers were being judged for keeping these
practices. Sha’ul forbad such judgement; non-Jews are free to participate in
them. They are a shadow of what has not come yet! Though the reality is
Christ, Sh’aul does not say they are obsolete; they point to a future
fulfilment. The Bible presents those who keep rosh chodesh rightly as
righteous, and provides good reason to celebrate it—including eager
anticipation of Messiah’s return to renew all things.
PS: A handout for this post is available for download here.
Even better insight for interpreting Colossians 2:16-17 is offered by Brian Allen in his 2018 paper, "Removing an Arrow from the Supersessionist Quiver." Hope to follow up on this sometime.
ReplyDeleteAllen, Brian Louis. 2018. “Removing an Arrow from the Supersessionist Quiver: A Post-Supersessionist Reading of Colossians 2:16–17.” Journal for the Study of Paul and His Letters 8. Penn State University Press:127–46.